Guardians spring training guide: 58 notes for 58 players, from Allen to Zunino
Cleveland Guardians starting pitcher Shane Bieber, right, slaps hands with catcher Meibrys Viloria during the first day of MLB spring training baseball workouts for Guardians pitchers and catchers in Goodyear, Ariz., Friday, Feb. 17, 2023. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin)
By Zack Meisel
3h ago
GOODYEAR, Ariz. — Here’s a handy guide on the 58 players in the Guardians’ big-league camp, with insights on where each player stands heading into the 2023 season. Use it as a resource throughout spring training.
Logan Allen, SP: This is the fourth consecutive year a starting pitcher with this name and with at least one Top 100 prospect list nod is in big-league camp. Can Allen prove he belongs in the Daniel Espino/Gavin Williams/Tanner Bibee conversation? He’d never had a hiccup in the minors until he reached Triple A last summer, when he posted a 6.49 ERA in 14 starts for Columbus. He has only 244 innings as a professional — Shane Bieber, for example, was a quick riser and still logged 283 innings; despite missing time with injuries, Triston McKenzie had 350 — so there’s still time for Allen to establish himself. When Allen visited Cleveland late last season for the team’s fall development program, the team’s message to him was for it not to have to hold the same meeting in 2023 because he’d instead be sitting in the Guardians’ dugout.
Gabriel Arias, IF: Arias has been a spring training darling the past two years, so it’s not shocking he was involved in the club’s playoff series against the Yankees. … Well, sort of. No one would have forecasted he’d be starting at first base in October, especially after a rather uninspiring season at Triple A. Another sharp spring could land Arias an Opening Day roster spot, and then it’ll be up to him to capitalize on whatever opportunities he receives, given the Guardians’ infielders don’t rest very often. He’ll spend time in the outfield this spring to boost his versatility.
Manager Terry Francona: “We view Gabby as an everyday player at some point in his career. You look around right now, you have José (Ramírez), Amed (Rosario) and (Andrés) Giménez. ‘OK, what’s your best way to be able to impact the major-league club?’”
Caleb Baragar, RP: The 28-year-old spent parts of the 2020 and ’21 seasons in the Giants’ big-league bullpen, as he recorded a 2.78 ERA in 45 innings. The righty pitched for the Diamondbacks’ Triple-A affiliate in 2022, when he logged a 5.51 ERA with more than a strikeout per inning. Baragar was a ninth-round draft choice out of Indiana University.
Peyton Battenfield, SP: Cleveland had 17 rookies debut last season, and that doesn’t include Battenfield, who joined the team for a weekend trip to Toronto in August in place of James Karinchak. Battenfield never entered a game, though, and after the series, he returned to Triple A. The 25-year-old, acquired in 2021 for Jordan Luplow, saw his strikeout rate plummet, his walk rate nearly double and his hit rate increase last season, his first with Columbus. He has a lot of competition at the top of the minor-league starting pitching pecking order.
Josh Bell, 1B: Cleveland’s marquee signing this winter, Bell will don a Guardians uniform for only one season if all goes well, because he has an opt-out clause that could make him a free agent in the offseason. Assistant hitting coach Victor Rodríguez shared he’s particularly excited about the protection Bell can provide José Ramírez in the lineup. Bell’s home run totals have fluctuated during his career, but he’s a safe bet to draw a ton of walks and make a bunch of contact. He’s also intrigued by the possibility of being able to pull more pitches with defensive shift restrictions in place. He owns a career .810 OPS.
More on Bell’s fit with the Guardians
Shane Bieber, SP: We can discuss how Bieber navigated his way through lineups last season despite diminished velocity or how he has only two seasons of team control remaining, but let’s instead focus on the big picture: He’s the club’s ace, and since becoming a full-time member of the rotation in 2019, he owns a 2.91 ERA across nearly 600 innings, with nearly 11 strikeouts per nine. He rebounded from shoulder issues in 2021 to reach the 200-inning mark last season and then dazzled in a pair of postseason starts. Bieber said he’s thrilled to have had a normal, healthy offseason. He started his throwing program a couple of weeks after the season ended, and maintained it during his Caribbean honeymoon by playing catch with locals.
More on Bieber’s under-the-radar stellar 2022
Jason Bilous, RP: The Guardians claimed Bilous off waivers from the White Sox earlier this month. The 25-year-old has consistently posted sound strikeout rates through the minors, but he’s constantly pitching with traffic. He has allowed nearly a hit per inning as well as more than five walks per nine. He has spent most of his professional career as a starter, but the Guardians view him as a reliever.
Will Brennan, OF: There’s not much left for Brennan to prove in the minors. He torched Double A and Triple A pitching last season before a September call-up to the majors. He’s a doubles machine, with 68 in 231 games the past two years. He slashed .314/.371/.479 and added 20 stolen bases in 2022. But where does he fit on the Guardians? Steven Kwan, Myles Straw and Oscar Gonzalez are expected to form the starting outfield, which could limit Brennan’s chances to prove he can make life miserable for major-league pitchers.
Juan Brito, IF: Brito might be the player in big-league camp with the most limited track record, which only adds to the intrigue. He turned 21 at the end of last season and then the Rockies dealt him to Cleveland for Nolan Jones. He fits the Guardians mold: high-contact, sound plate discipline, middle infielder. Last season in A-ball, he posted a .286/.407/.470 slash line, with 17 stolen bases and more walks than strikeouts. There are questions about whether he makes enough hard contact, and whether his 46 extra-base hits in 107 games suggest there’s more power in his future. But there’s time to figure it all out since he’s likely ticketed for Double-A Akron.
Joey Cantillo, SP: Cantillo’s fastball sat in the 88 to 90 mph range when Cleveland acquired him from San Diego in the Mike Clevinger trade in 2020. Last offseason, the club placed him on a velocity program and — voila! — he was sitting 93 to 95 mph before an injury interfered with his 2022 season. He has a quality changeup, and throws a curveball and slider as well. The team was conservative with his injury recovery because they were pleased with the progress he had made. Now, he could start the season in Triple-A Columbus’ rotation and be one call away from a major-league debut.
More on Cantillo’s development
Aaron Civale, SP: Civale logged a 3.24 ERA and limited opponents to a .262 on-base percentage over his final 14 starts last season. The problem? Those 14 starts took place over a stretch from mid-May to early October because he kept landing on the injured list. He made three starts in May, two in June, three in July (and left the third after one inning) and then missed the first three weeks of September. It’s clear what his key is for 2023: learning how to implement a new gyroball. OK, no, it’s health, which can pave the way for more consistency, which can allow him to resemble the guy who anchored Cleveland’s staff in the first half of the 2021 season.
Emmanuel Clase, RP: If he’s not the No. 1 reliever in baseball, he’s 1A. His 100 mph cutter is one of baseball’s most distinctive pitches, and his slider actually proved even more effective in 2022, as opponents slugged .174 against it with a 42.7 percent whiff rate. He registered a 1.29 ERA in 2021, and somehow got better in 2022. Sure, his strikeout rate increased and his walk rate decreased, but his efficiency is the best way to convey how dominant he was: He made 70 appearances totaling one inning, and needed 20 or more pitches in only four of them; on 27 occasions, he needed 10 pitches or fewer. If you sneezed, you probably missed his 1-2-3 ninth inning.
More on Clase’s dominance
Zack Collins, C: The No. 10 draft pick in 2016 — two picks after Cal Quantrill, four picks ahead of Will Benson, 45 picks ahead of Nolan Jones, two rounds ahead of Civale, three rounds ahead of Bieber and 11 rounds ahead of Zach Plesac — Collins bounced from Toronto to Pittsburgh last season after spending his first three big-league seasons with the White Sox. Offensively, he has a three-true-outcomes profile, with a lot of walks and strikeouts and some power.
Xzavion Curry, SP: Along the back wall on the left side of the Guardians’ spring clubhouse, Peyton Battenfield, Curry, Hunter Gaddis and Joey Cantillo have lockers in succession. All four are in similar spots, attempting to be on the mind of Cleveland’s decision-makers when the Guardians need a starting pitcher this season. Curry made a couple of spot starts last summer. He cruised through the club’s farm system in two years after beginning his professional career in A-ball in 2021.
Enyel De Los Santos, RP: A nondescript signing before the lockout a year and a half ago, De Los Santos turned out to be a valuable addition, with a 3.04 ERA in 50 appearances. His season also included an immaculate inning (the fourth in team history), though he didn’t realize it until he asked teammates why they were celebrating upon his return to the dugout. He didn’t break camp with the team last season, but pitching coach Carl Willis assured him he’d contribute to the bullpen at some point. Sure enough, he did. He probably doesn’t have to have those concerns this year, as long as he shakes off a tweaked hamstring.
Phillip Diehl, RP: The Cincinnati native has pitched briefly for the Rockies and Reds, and the lefty owns a 3.50 ERA in the minors, with 11 strikeouts per nine innings. Last season, the Reds traded Diehl and former Cleveland outfielder Tyler Naquin to the Mets for a pair of prospects.
Tyler Freeman, IF: The king of contact made his debut last season and, unsurprisingly, demonstrated he’s just as averse to strikeouts against big-league pitching. The question is, can he hit the ball hard enough and find enough holes in the defense to produce consistently at the plate? And, is there a role available to give him the opportunity to do so? He’s vying for an Opening Day roster spot, but for now, the infield is set and Gabriel Arias is also bidding for the utility infielder gig.
David Fry, C: Fry bounced around the infield at Northwestern State and with the Brewers, and he played catcher and corner infield for the Guardians last season. He posted a .779 OPS for Columbus and then played in the Arizona Fall League as he worked on his skills behind the plate with Cleveland’s coaches at the team’s complex. The Guardians have seven catchers in camp, but that number will decrease to five when the World Baseball Classic begins, so the plan is for Fry to move around defensively early in camp so he gets enough at-bats, then help out more behind the plate as the spring unfolds.
Terry Francona: “It’s kind of a unique skill set.”
Hunter Gaddis, SP: Gaddis would love nothing more than a chance to tack some big-league appearances onto his record, if for no other reason than to wipe away the 18.41 ERA that jumps off his Baseball Reference page. That’s the result from his two spot starts last season. As Terry Francona likes to say, those fill-in assignments won’t define his career, but they did offer him a taste of the big leagues.
“You just want to be a piece of it the whole time,” Gaddis said. “It motivates you beyond belief. I can’t even put it into words, really.”
He seems like a safe bet to start the year with Triple-A Columbus. Gaddis lives in the Atlanta area but spent time in Arizona over the winter to train with the organization’s coaches. What did he learn from last season?
“Belief,” he said. “I’m in a much better spot than ever before. Mentally, physically, all of the above.”
Cam Gallagher, C: One of a handful of contenders for the backup catcher role, the 30-year-old spent parts of the past six seasons spelling Salvador Perez in Kansas City. Gallagher, who like third-base coach Mike Sarbaugh hails from Lancaster, Pa., owns a .240/.302/.355 slash line in the majors. He was a second-round pick by the Royals in 2011. His brother and father were third-round selections.
Andrés Giménez, 2B: From last spring’s guide: “This is a pivotal season for Giménez to prove he deserves regular playing time.” Uh, mission accomplished. He started at second base in the All-Star Game, won a Gold Glove Award and finished sixth in the American League MVP balloting. The goal for 2023? Do it again. In the meantime, he’ll play for Team Venezuela in the World Baseball Classic.
More on Giménez’s journey to stardom
Oscar Gonzalez, RF: A year ago, Gonzalez was somewhat of an afterthought, a non-roster invitee to big-league camp who wound up debuting in the majors two months later and starring as an October hero after that. Now, can he exhibit enough plate discipline to stick as the club’s everyday right fielder? He flashed his power potential more as the season went on (he also tallied 27 doubles in only 91 games), but his tendency to chase pitches out of the zone — Gonzalez, Javier Báez, Salvador Perez and Luis Robert Jr. were the four worst offenders in chase rate in 2022 — could convince pitchers to avoid offering him anything in the zone.
More on Gonzalez’s rise to the majors
Sam Hentges, RP: Cleveland tossed Hentges into the fire in 2021 out of necessity, thanks to a rash of starting rotation injuries and a lack of major-league-ready depth, due in part to the lost 2020 minor-league season. Hentges shifted to a relief role in 2022 and, as the season unfolded, he answered whether he could earn late-inning trust by logging a 2.32 ERA, with healthy metrics to back it up. He found results from his always-dependable curveball (.130 opponent slugging percentage) and from mixing in more two-seam fastballs (.127 opponent average).
Tim Herrin, RP: Herrin was working an offseason job at a Lululemon store when Cleveland’s director of player development called one evening in November to tell him he was being added to the 40-man roster. The 6 p.m. deadline had passed and Herrin was fielding texts from family members who were curious about the team’s decision. The transaction means he has a chance to land an Opening Day bullpen spot, which didn’t sink in to Herrin until he arrived in Goodyear. Even if he doesn’t break camp with the team, he should join the group at some point this season. The Guardians have only one lefty — Sam Hentges — in position to make the pen. Herrin said he plans to lean on Hentges this spring, since they’re both tall, hard-throwing southpaws. Herrin, a 29th-round pick with gaudy minor-league strikeout totals, said he wants to learn “what (Hentges is) thinking on the mound and how he approaches hitters, what he’s looking for, stuff like that.”
James Karinchak, RP: Karinchak’s fastball? Extremely effective (.211 opponent slugging percentage). Karinchak’s curveball? Supremely effective (48.6 percent whiff rate). Last year, he rebounded from a spring injury to again cement himself as a reliable setup man. The only question this year is whether the pitch clock will haunt him and interfere with his between-pitch ritual of flipping the baseball in his glove, running his hand through his hair and rubbing the rosin bag. That’s quite the checklist for a 15-second timeframe (20 seconds with men on base).
Michael Kelly, RP: Kelly was a first-round pick in 2011, but by 2019, he was pitching for the Southern Maryland Blue Crabs of the independent Atlantic League. Then, the pandemic arrived, and Kelly thought his major-league dreams had been dashed. But he was instructing kids at a baseball facility in Chattanooga, Tenn., and he kept training on the side.
“I was working out so I could help (the kids), and the workouts kept me hooked, kept me going,” he said. “I kept throwing and kept seeing improvements.”
He latched on with the Phillies and received the long-awaited call to the majors in June while in Omaha, Neb., with Triple-A Lehigh Valley. He made four appearances for the team that wound up winning the National League pennant. Now, he’s competing for a bullpen spot with Cleveland. Earlier in his career, that assignment would come with plenty of pressure. But now?
“My journey has made me realize it’s a privilege to play the game of baseball,” he said.
Dusten Knight, RP: Knight made cameos for the Orioles and Rays the past two years after posting solid numbers in the minors for nearly a decade. He was originally a 28th-round pick by the Giants in 2013. Former Giants first baseman Will Clark once saw him do a backflip in the outfield and suggested he do one after recording a save.
Steven Kwan, LF: It’s a much more relaxed spring for Kwan, who last year was attempting — in a frenzied, shortened camp — to prove himself to the organization’s decision-makers. He has a third-place finish in the AL Rookie of the Year voting and a Gold Glove Award to his name, plus peace of mind in knowing he’s the Opening Day left fielder. More than anything, he said, he can feel more confident at the plate this season knowing he belongs in the big leagues.
More on Kwan’s rookie season
Bryan Lavastida, C: What started out as a dream opportunity quickly fizzled into a rough year for Lavastida, who broke camp with the major-league team (thanks to an injury to Luke Maile) last spring. Lavastida ended up enduring a slump-filled, injury-riddled season at Double-A Akron and Triple-A Columbus. But he’s on the 40-man roster, which can help his cause (you know, as long as he hangs onto that spot). He’s in the mix to compete for the backup catcher gig.
Angel Martinez, SS: The Guardians added Martinez to the 40-man roster in November, and it wouldn’t be surprising to see him burst onto the Top 100 prospect scene within the next year. He’s adept at second base, shortstop and third base, and played at all three positions in the Arizona Fall League. The Guardians treasure his contact ability and are encouraged by his power potential. Martinez reached Double A as a 20-year-old last year and posted an .849 OPS in 101 games overall.
Triston McKenzie, SP: Armed with confidence that he possessed big-league ability, McKenzie authored a breakout season in 2022, with a 2.96 ERA and, perhaps most important, 191 injury-free innings. Opponents mustered a .253 on-base percentage against him. What can he do for an encore? As he likes to say, “Consistency is key.”
More on McKenzie’s breakout season
Nick Mikolajchak, RP: Mikolajchak’s ERA improved from Double A in 2021 to Triple A in 2022, but that’s a bit misleading. He had some struggles as he attempted to unearth the optimal pitch mix that would keep him dominating more advanced hitters. His walk rate more than doubled and his strikeout rate sharply decreased. When he’s at his best, his fastball sits 94 to 96 mph, to go along with a curveball and slider.
Andrew Misiaszek, RP: Misiaszek, a former teammate of Aaron Civale at Northeastern, had a brilliant 2022 season, with a 2.04 ERA and 90 strikeouts in 61 innings between Double-A Akron and Triple-A Columbus. That placed the 32nd-round draft pick on the Guardians’ radar and earned him a non-roster invite, but he’s dealing with an elbow injury that required a PRP injection, so he’ll be merely an observer in big-league camp.
Eli Morgan, RP: Morgan has come a long way from the rookie who was nearly blown into Lake Erie during his debut amid hurricane-like conditions in 2021. He was an instrumental part of the Guardians’ bullpen in 2022 until the home-run ball plagued him for a summer stretch. His changeup and slider kept hitters off-balance and prevented them from sitting on his 92 mph fastball.
Cody Morris, SP: Morris’ 2021 performance had many in the organization anticipating his major-league arrival. A lat strain delayed his big-league debut until September 2022. He made seven appearances for the club and then tossed two perfect innings against the Yankees in Game 4 of the ALDS. Now, he’s again dealing with lat discomfort, so he’ll be brought along a bit slowly this spring. The team is still working through the ideal role for him, but a job as a multi-inning reliever is in consideration.
Bo Naylor, C: Naylor is, barring some changes, likely ticketed for Triple-A Columbus to start the season, but he also could play a prominent role in the team’s catching plans in 2023, given his ceiling and the fact that he debuted last year. He flushed a dismal 2021 season by producing a display of power, patience and speed in 2022. He’ll spend the spring building a rapport with the club’s pitchers, though he’ll miss time while he suits up for Team Canada in the WBC.
Terry Francona: “We tell them, ‘It’s not always on your timetable.’ We own up to that. But if you knock the door down, that makes the timetable. But I think he has a really good head. He’s situated really well. He has a pretty good outlook.”
Josh Naylor, 1B: Naylor said “it wasn’t easy” to push through lower leg pain to play on a daily basis last season, but he’s hopeful this year will be different, since he benefited from having a normal offseason training regimen. Bell’s presence should allow him to spend time at designated hitter if needed, but Terry Francona has voiced his preference to at least have Naylor available as an outfield option. The big question for Naylor this season is whether he can shake his struggles against southpaws, who limited him to a .236 slugging percentage in 2022.
Jhonkensy Noel, 1B: Noel, who’s built like an NFL edge rusher, smacked 32 home runs and 26 doubles last season, mostly between High-A Lake County and Double-A Akron. No surprise there. Along with all that power, though, came a tendency to swing-and-miss. He totaled 150 strikeouts in 548 plate appearances. Noel made a cameo at Triple A last season, so it’s not impossible that he debuts in 2023, though things would have to fall in place to create an opening for him, and he’d have to prove he can make more contact to seize such an opportunity. Next year is a more plausible timeline.
Luis Oviedo, RP: Cleveland signed Oviedo on the international market in July 2015. The Mets selected him in the Rule 5 draft in 2020 but then flipped him to the Pirates, who lost him on waivers last April to Cleveland. The circle of (baseball) life. He’s in camp as a non-roster invitee after spending the bulk of last season at Double-A Akron. Oviedo is a fastball/curveball/slider guy who throws in the mid-90s but has had some command issues.
Richie Palacios, OF: With Nolan Jones and Will Benson no longer part of the outfield equation, Palacios could earn more playing time this season. He’ll join his brother on Team Netherlands in the WBC, so he’ll miss some time in camp, but the Guardians did gain at least a semblance of an idea last season of what he has to offer when he appeared in 54 games.
Konnor Pilkington, SP: The Mississippi native, acquired in 2021 from the White Sox for César Hernández, broke camp with the big-league club last year, one of the surprises of the spring. His role was to protect the team’s starters after the hastened, post-lockout spring training. He ended up logging a 3.88 ERA in 58 innings for the Guardians and figures to occupy a similar “call me if you need anything” role in 2023.
Zach Plesac, SP: Plesac’s forgettable 2022 season culminated with a knuckle sandwich to the mound in Seattle in late August, which resulted in a broken hand. He’s still under team control for three more seasons, but he’s had a below-average ERA+ in each of the past two years.
2021: 142 innings, 4.67 ERA, 137 hits, 34 walks, 100 strikeouts
2022: 131 innings, 4.31 ERA, 136 hits, 38 walks, 100 strikeouts
Micah Pries, 1B/LF: Cleveland’s 13th-round pick in 2019, Pries will turn 25 at the end of February. He lost the post-draft portion of 2019 because of an elbow injury and lost his 2020 season because of the pandemic, so he spent 2021 in A-ball trying to make up for lost time. He reached Double-A Akron in 2022. Overall, he owns an .843 OPS as a professional. His offensive profile is intriguing, with 18 home runs and 20 stolen bases last season. Defensively, he has played first base and all three outfield spots. The organization is prioritizing first base, left field and right field for him in 2023. His grandfather, Don, a longtime Orioles executive, scouted for Cleveland in 1963.
Cal Quantrill, SP: Projection systems might be skeptical of him, but it’s hard to argue with Quantrill’s performance since joining the Guardians in 2020: a 3.11 ERA in 350 innings. So, how does he outperform his metrics and peripheral numbers? Good walk and home run rates help, and he’s done a decent job of limiting hard contact. So, while Steamer projects a 4.61 ERA, The Bat says 4.51 and ZiPS suggests 4.08, here’s guessing those predictions will end up selling Quantrill short.
Roman Quinn, OF: Quinn has consistently ranked near the top of the sprint speed and arm strength leaderboards during his career. His profile isn’t too dissimilar from the club’s starting center fielder, Myles Straw: speed and defense, and a career .651 OPS in six seasons with the Phillies and Rays. Might his skill set prove more valuable with the league’s new rule changes?
“It’s for the base stealer’s advantage,” he said. “I’m excited about it.”
He said he fits in well with a team that was aggressive on the bases and prioritized speed and defense last season.
“That’s what my game is built around,” he said.
The 29-year-old also had one other observation about his new surroundings.
“Being drafted in 2011,” he said, “I feel like the old head in here.”
José Ramírez, 3B: Ramírez has a decent shot at making the Opening Day roster. … OK, really, he’s healthy after dealing with a torn thumb ligament last summer, which required surgery after the season (only because he refused to be sidelined during the season). Last year at this time, he and the Guardians were engaged in a roller-coaster negotiation process on a long-term extension. This year, no such distractions. And no defenses stacking their infielders on the right side of the infield or deploying four outfielders when he steps into the batter’s box.
More on what makes Ramírez the face of the franchise
Brayan Rocchio, SS: It seems as though we’ve been discussing the well-regarded shortstop prospect for a decade, but he just turned 22 in January. He reached Triple-A Columbus last season and that’s likely where he’ll start in 2023, which means he’d be one call away from the majors. But he’d need some dominoes to fall to play a significant role on the big-league club this year, with Andrés Giménez and Amed Rosario firmly entrenched up the middle, plus Gabriel Arias and Tyler Freeman snooping around. The Athletic’s Keith Law considers Rocchio Cleveland’s top prospect and No. 22 overall in the sport.
Amed Rosario, SS: Rosario is entering his final season before he’s eligible for free agency, and he could be the prized shortstop of the class. If history is any indication, he’ll post a slash line in the vicinity of .280/.315/.405, with 11 home runs, 25 doubles, 20 stolen bases and a 4-to-1 strikeout-to-walk ratio.
Nick Sandlin, RP: Sandlin made some mechanical tweaks during a midseason visit to Triple A. When he returned to the Guardians, he was lights out, his command issues a distant memory. He allowed three earned runs in his final 26 appearances. The sidearmer owns a 2.55 ERA in 80 games with Cleveland. Now, can he complete a full season without a trip to the injured list or the minors?
Caleb Simpson, RP: He was a catcher at Seminole State College, but the Giants drafted him in 2013 as a pitcher. Simpson has spent time with the Giants, Cubs and Red Sox but has yet to pitch in the majors. He owns a 4.20 ERA in the minors, with high walk (6.3 per nine innings) and strikeout (11.5 per nine) rates.
Cade Smith, RP: The native of Abbotsford, British Columbia, was not selected in the five-round 2020 amateur draft. The Guardians recruited him over Zoom after the fact and a couple of years later, the reliever is on the team’s big-league radar. His stuff has ticked up the longer he’s been in the organization, with his fastball now sitting 93 to 94 mph and topping out at 96 mph. He tallied 99 strikeouts in 61 innings last season at High-A Lake County and Double-A Akron and recorded a 2.93 ERA. He had a pretty high walk rate, but limited opponents to a .229 slugging percentage. He didn’t allow many hits in general, but he surrendered only one home run.
Trevor Stephan, RP: Stephan is an apt study into Cleveland’s pitching development prowess. The club snagged him in the Rule 5 draft from the Yankees two years ago. He spent one season pitching mop-up duty and then in 2022, he soared toward the top of Terry Francona’s reliever trust rankings, thanks in large part to a devastating splitter that armed him with three quality pitches. He more than tripled his splitter usage in 2022; opponents slugged .224 against it.
More on Stephan’s arsenal
Myles Straw, CF: Straw earned a well-deserved Gold Glove Award for his patrolling of center field. He also ranked in the 94th percentile in sprint speed, which could pay dividends with the new rule changes. He’ll need to figure out how to convert his elite contact and chase rates into more hits. He did hit .330 over the final month of the season and he spent a week in Cleveland in December working with coaches on his swing.
Jose Tena, SS: A year ago, Keith Law ranked Tena as Cleveland’s fourth-best prospect and No. 68 in baseball, but a pedestrian showing at Double-A Akron tempered expectations. He struck out 138 times and walked only 25 en route to a .264/.299/.411 slash line. That dropped Tena from the Top 100 and shifted him to No. 10 in the system. Law did write Tena demonstrated “enough to hold out hope for further improvement,” labeling him a plus defender at shortstop who has “the upside of a strong regular or a bit more.”
Touki Toussaint, RP: The Guardians view Toussaint, a former first-round pick and top-50 prospect, as a potential multi-inning reliever. He’s still only 26, with big-league experience in each of the past five seasons with the Braves and Angels. His hurdle has been command (5.5 walks per nine innings). He wields a punishing curveball, and he’s found success with his splitter, too.
George Valera, RF: There seems to be some industry debate about Valera’s ceiling as a major-league hitter and whether he can make enough contact to be more than a platoon corner outfielder who often succumbs to the three true outcomes. (Law ranked him the No. 27 prospect in baseball, for what it’s worth.) We might get an idea as soon as this summer. Valera reached Triple A last summer, so if he can show some refinement in Columbus, he could be ready for a big-league opportunity.
Meibrys Viloria, C: If it wasn’t Cam Gallagher serving as Salvador Perez’s backup with the Royals in recent years, it was usually Viloria. He’ll play for Team Colombia in the WBC, which could cost him time to familiarize himself with Cleveland’s pitching staff. For now, though, he’s part of the competition to share time behind the plate with Mike Zunino.
Mike Zunino, C: The Guardians will be careful with Zunino this spring as he returns from thoracic outlet syndrome surgery on his non-throwing arm, but he is expected to be in the lineup for the Cactus League opener Saturday, which is an encouraging sign. The veteran catcher has a boom-or-bust profile at the plate and a strong reputation behind it. He signed a one-year, $6 million deal to replace Austin Hedges.