You are welcome civ.
To sign or not to sign? Indians players reflect on their MLB Draft decisions
By Zack Meisel May 31, 2019 6
Tito Francona had a son on the way and he needed some extra cash in his pocket, so he asked Tigers general manager John McHale for a $500 raise.
McHale told him to get lost. Detroit dealt Tito to Cleveland for Larry Doby in March 1959. Terry Francona was born a month later.
Terry starred in high school in New Brighton, Pa., but separated his shoulder during his senior season. The Cubs still selected him in the second round of the draft and offered him an $18,000 signing bonus. Terry was eyeing a sum closer to $40,000, so he planned to attend the University of Arizona.
But as the first class of his first semester approached, Terry grew homesick and started to regret not signing. Clubs could negotiate with their draft picks until a player attended his first college class. Tito checked with the Cubs to see whether they would increase their final offer.
They did — to $19,000.
Terry went to class.
The Expos selected Terry, who captured the Golden Spikes Award (top college player), with the 22nd overall pick in the 1980 draft. The Wildcats won the College World Series, and Terry was named the tournament’s Most Outstanding Player. He was concerned about his grades, though, and thought if he didn’t sign with the Expos, he might have to take summer classes.
Ah, but he had some leverage, in the form of his father, who negotiated with the Expos on his behalf.
Who was Montreal’s general manager? McHale.
“Do you remember that son that I wanted the $500 for?” Tito asked McHale. “Well, it’s going to cost you a lot more now.”
The Expos offered Terry a $100,000 signing bonus, which he accepted.
Every player has his own tale about the draft process, which places loads of responsibility (and stress) upon the shoulders of aspiring athletes who haven’t even reached the legal drinking age.
Should I sign and forgo college? Can I afford to pass up this money? Can I improve my draft stock over the next few years? Do I have a backup plan?
With the draft set to begin Monday, here are some Indians players’ recollections of the demanding decision process.
Terry Francona at Arizona in 1979. (Arizona / Collegiate Images / Getty Images)
Tyler Clippard
Selected by the Yankees in the ninth round of the 2003 draft out of high school
Clippard had leaned toward not signing unless he was drafted in the first three rounds, which he knew was unlikely. But he attended high school outside of Tampa, and the Yankees drafted him, so his decision boiled down to whether he wanted to go to the University of South Florida, near Tampa, or play rookie ball at the Yankees’ rookie league team — in Tampa. He opted to sign.
“It’s way too much, the whole process,” Clippard said. “I just remember the scouts and the farm directors and organizations, when they talk to you, they always want you to tell them, ‘What would it take for you to sign?’ I know now it’s slot money and it’s a little different story, but then, it was, ‘How much would it take for you to sign?’ It was up to an 18-year-old to say, ‘I’ll sign for $200,000.’ Looking back on that, I was telling teams that number, and I’m like, ‘Why was I saying that? It was so stupid.’ It’s just a weird deal. It’s a whirlwind. You don’t realize it. I didn’t have an agent at all. I was just out on an island. It was just me and my dad talking. It’s like, ‘How the hell do you do that stuff?’ ”
Jason Kipnis
Selected by the Padres in the fourth round of the 2008 draft out of Arizona State
Selected by the Indians in the second round of the 2009 draft out of Arizona State
Kipnis had some leverage in 2008, since he was a redshirt sophomore. He could return to school if he didn’t sign, and had two years of eligibility remaining, two chances to boost his stock.
“Combine that with, I think I was being offered under-slot,” Kipnis said. “It was one of those ones where after I got drafted, I was like, ‘These guys never got to our number.’ They’re like, ‘Well, you never told us a number.’ I was like, ‘Well, you never asked, either.’ So there really wasn’t the greatest communication between me and the Padres. I think, at the time, I didn’t realize just how risky turning down the fourth round is.”
His experience at Arizona State had some influence, too. When he started at the University of Kentucky, he didn’t know much about the draft process. At Arizona State, first-round prospects and visits from scouts were the norm.
“I’m just like, ‘What is this place?’ ” Kipnis said.
After Kipnis’ junior year, the Indians selected him in the second round. His patience paid dividends.
“There are certain parts,” Kipnis said, “where it’s like, ‘Are you sure you want to ask for this much more?’ And I was like, ‘Yeah!’ I didn’t really realize what I was doing. It’s a big decision. That’s why you need to surround yourself with the right people, the right group you trust that has your best interests in mind.”
Dan Otero
Selected by the Giants in the 21st round of the 2007 draft out of South Florida
Otero’s father, Jorge, provided a stern message to anyone who sniffed around his son’s draft plans: “There’s probably not enough money out there for him to sign and skip college.”
“I come from a big academic, prideful family,” Otero said. “Get an education. Go to school. He was like, ‘I want you to go to school, unless …’ ”
… unless he could secure a $1 million signing bonus. And that wasn’t happening. Otero wasn’t drafted out of high school, and he’s grateful his father set such a high standard for him.
“I don’t know if I would’ve been able to survive in pro ball as an 18-year-old kid without going to college,” he said.
In 2007, after time at Duke and South Florida, Otero was chosen in the 21st round by the Giants. He was monitoring the draft on his dad’s laptop when he received a call from a number with a Massachusetts area code. It was a Giants scout who covered the northeast and southeast regions.
“I was just hoping to get drafted,” he said. “It was after my senior year. I didn’t do anything to light up the radar guns or the stat sheet. I didn’t have 15 strikeouts per nine innings. The only thing I did was not walk guys.”
Otero received a $2,500 signing bonus, a plane ticket to Scottsdale and his choice of Rawlings glove from a stash at the team’s complex.
Mike Freeman
Selected by the Padres in the 41st round of the 2006 draft out of high school
Selected by the Diamondbacks in the 36th round of the 2009 draft out of Clemson
Selected by the Diamondbacks in the 11th round of the 2010 draft out of Clemson
Freeman is a rare case, a player drafted out of high school and twice in college. And even more surprising: None of his decisions was difficult to make.
Freeman was fixated on attending Clemson, and being the 1,233rd overall pick in the 2006 draft wasn’t going to change that. He felt committed in 2009 to complete his college career, and only a severe overpay could sway him; that wasn’t going to happen as a 36th rounder. That year, the Diamondbacks also encouraged him to participate in the Cape Cod League so more members of their front office could watch him. But Freeman had already played in the league and he preferred to take some classes over the summer instead.
So, he returned to school. It proved wise. Clemson advanced to the College World Series, and Freeman jumped to the 11th round.
“I wanted to finish school,” he said, “and I knew money wasn’t going to be an issue if I wanted to go into the working field. I was fortunate to be drafted three times. Pretty unique.”
Jake Bauers
Selected by the Padres in the seventh round of the 2013 draft out of high school
Bauers was certain he wanted to forgo college and play professionally right away. When scouts started visiting his house, it only strengthened his stance.
“I really put all my focus into that,” Bauers said, “and I kind of lived and died on each pick and I slid a little bit further than I thought I was going to, so it was pretty stressful for two days. I finally got picked up and obviously went and played and it worked out all right.”
Tyler Olson
Selected by the Athletics in the 17th round of the 2012 draft out of Gonzaga
Selected by the Mariners in the seventh round of the 2013 draft out of Gonzaga
Olson might have signed with Oakland had the price been more to his liking. He didn’t mind returning for his senior year, as it allowed him to complete the coursework for his double major: physical education and sports management.
“You never really know what it’s like until you go through it,” Olson said. “You talk to a scout or whoever it is that’s signing you and you go through the process, but you don’t really know what’s going on.”
Scott Atchison
Selected by the Mariners in the 36th round of the 1994 draft out of high school
Selected by the Mariners in the 49th round of the 1998 draft out of TCU
The 49th round doesn’t even exist anymore. The draft now only lasts 40 rounds.
Atchison had no intention of signing out of high school, and the Mariners acknowledged they couldn’t compete with the perks of his scholarship to TCU.
Atchison missed his third season at TCU because of injury, and he posted a 7.52 ERA upon his return in 1998, so he didn’t expect to be drafted.
“I had been pretty bad,” Atchison said. “That was my fourth year. I was doing a summer camp for the school and our SID (sports information director) came up and said, ‘Hey, the Mariners are talking about taking you.’ I was like, ‘Oh, OK.’ They called and said, ‘We took you in the 49th round.’ But you could draft-and-follow fifth-year seniors, so I still had another year of eligibility because of the injury. They were like, ‘We’re not going to try to sign you right now. Go back, have your fifth year. We just want your rights before the draft next year, because we think you’re going to bounce back well.’ I did, and there was some negotiation at that point, but as a fifth-year guy, I didn’t have much of a choice of anything.”
The signing process the following year was still a bit chaotic.
“We had just finished the conference tournament and if we had gotten to regionals,” Atchison said, “I would’ve had to go back into the draft because I couldn’t have signed and still be in college. We ended up not getting a bid. We finished second in the tournament and ended up not getting into a regional. They called me at, like, 9 a.m. and we had to have it done by 4 or 5 that evening. It wasn’t a long process, but you’re having to fax and do different things because it was before people were shooting emails.”