Brayan Rocchio, who is trying to win the shortstop's job for the Guardians, homered and doubled in his first two at-bats Monday against the White Sox at Camelback Ranch in Glendale, Arizona.
[Followed up that outing with a pair of hits today including a double]
It’s still a coin flip at shortstop: Guardians spring training breakfast
Updated: Mar. 19, 2024, 3:51 p.m.|Published: Mar. 19, 2024, 9:37 a.m.
By Paul Hoynes, cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- If you’ve spent all spring trying to pick a winner at shortstop for the Guardians, you should rip up your tickets and go home. The main contenders, Gabriel Arias and Brayan Rocchio, never left the gate.
Then they go and have a game like Monday’s exhibition against the White Sox. What’s a talent evaluator to think?
Rocchio, hitting leadoff and playing short, started the game with a double to ignite a six-run inning. Arias, after being knocked down by a viral infection earlier in the camp, contributed to the big inning with a home run.
In the second, Rocchio responded by starting the inning with his first home run of the spring.
Other than that, Rocchio and Arias have been mostly spectators in the desert. At least between the lines. They’ve allowed the rest of the field — Tyler Freeman, Angel Martinez and Jose Tena — to close on them. Lately, Freeman has been fighting a virus and Martinez has been hobbled by a bruised toe.
Arias, who had the job handed to him after Amed Rosario was traded at the deadline last year, is hitting .160 (4 for 25) with one double, one homer and two RBI. He has eight strikeouts and two walks.
Rocchio is hitting .242 (6 for 33) with three doubles, one homer and two RBI.
Manager Stephen Vogt has said all spring that game performances aren’t the only thing that will determine who wins a position. The ability to adjust and stick with those adjustments, the quality of work in practice and a player’s track record are taken into account.
All that is a good thing because right now it’s a coin flip on who will be Cleveland’s opening day shortstop.
Tough goodbye
The Guardians sent prospect Kyle Manzardo to minor league camp on Monday. The organization was excited about acquiring him from the Rays last year for Aaron Civale. When he recovered from a shoulder injury and performed well in the Arizona Fall League, many believed he had a chance to make the big league club this spring.
Here’s what Vogt told him Monday.
“It’s never fun when you tell someone they’re going to minor league camp,” said Vogt. “I tried to tell Kyle that he had a great camp. I really enjoyed his work. He really dove into the defense and baserunning. We all know he can hit and we saw flashes of that this spring.
“His at-bats are great. It’s just the understanding that he needs to go get consistent at-bats and continue to develop in that way.”
Manzardo hit .381 (8 for 21) with two RBI in 21 games. He’s expected to start the season at Class AAA Columbus.
The demotion means Rule 5 pick Deyvison De Los Santos has the inside track to be Josh Naylor’s right-handed complement at first base and DH.
Monday’s game
The Guardians hit three home runs and Tanner Bibee, with help from the re-entry rule, pitched 4 1/3 innings in a 8-5 spring win over the White Sox at Camelback Ranch.
DeLauter and Arias hit consecutive homers to highlight a six-run first inning by the Guards. Cleveland started the inning with six straight hits.
Rocchio opened the game with a double and scored on a single by Myles Straw. David Fry doubled Straw home and Austin Hedges moved Fry to third with a single. DeLauter followed with a three-run homer.
Bibee (2-1, 6.00) worked his way through three scoreless innings. He pitched himself into a one-out jam in the fourth when Trey Benton relieved and retired two straight to strand runners on first and second. Bibee came back for the fifth and retired the side in order.
Of course, there is no re-entry rule in the regular season.
The Guardians, 10-12-1 in the desert, finished with 12 hits. Rocchio, Hedges and Fry had two each.
Bryan Shaw, the pitching machine, worked a scoreless eighth inning for the White Sox. Shaw is the Guardians’ franchise leader in appearances.
Tuesday’s games
It’s a split-squad day for the Guardians. They will play the Brewers at Goodyear Ballpark at 4:05 p.m. ET. WTAM will carry the game.
Cleveland will send another team to Salt River Fields at Talking Stick in Scottsdale to play the Rockies at 4:05 p.m. MLB.com webcast will carry the game.
LHP Logan Allen (1-1, 21.6) will start against the Brewers and RHP Colin Rae (0-0, 2.55). Veteran Jamie Barria (0-1, 10.13) will make his first start of the spring against the Rockies and RHP Dakota Hudson (1-1, 6.74).
Allen is in line to start the third game of the regular season on March 30 against the A’s in Oakland. He’s had some control issues in his first three starts of the spring, walking six and striking out six, but he’s allowed just two earned runs in 8 1/3 innings. The opposition is hitting .154 against him.
Lineup vs. Brewers at Goodyear:
LF Steven Kwan, 3B Jose Ramirez, 1B Josh Naylor, RF Ramon Laureano, 2B Andres Gimenez, C Bo Naylor, CF Myles Straw, SS Brayan Rocchio, DH Deyvison De Los Santos and LHP Allen.
Lineup vs. Rockies at Salt River Fields:
CF Estevan Florial, SS Gabriel Arias, RF Will Brennan, 1B David Fry, C Austin Hedges, LF Chase DeLauter, 3B Daniel Schneemann, 2B Jose Tena, DH Dom Nunez and RHP Barria.
<