4472
by TFIR
Cleveland Indians' Jason Kipnis: an All-Star made, not born - Bud Shaw
CLEVELAND, Ohio – The most natural middle infielders glide (think Robbie Alomar).
Some are missing only the soundtrack from Swan Lake (Omar Vizquel).
The “heavy runners” leave the infield looking like the stretch run at the Kentucky Derby.
When Indians’ minor league instructors asked Jason Kipnis to leave the comfort of the outfield and take a bucket of ground balls for the first time in Arizona, the operative term was “chewed the dirt up.”
Kipnis showed great lateral movement but was understandably raw. His hands? About as soft as the sun-baked desert around him.
“Hideous,” Kipnis remembered. “I wasn’t really catching grounders as much as blocking them.”
Four years is a long time for some things. It’s an eternity for a souring relationship, for instance. It’s a losing proposition for a receding hairline to stand its ground for that long.
But it’s the fast track for a kid outfielder to do everything Kipnis has done since the 2009 position change.
It’s remarkable that he’s managed to make the tough transition “to the dirt” (as Tribe Director of Amateur Scouting Brad Grant calls it), keep hitting at every level of the minors, establish himself as an everyday player let alone leave a different kind of mark as a second baseman in an All-Star game in New York last July.
“It’s a really good story,” said former Indians’ GM John Hart, whose job as an analyst for MLB Network recently required a ranking of top second basemen.
“You’ve got (Robinson) Cano and (Dustin) Pedroia. (Ian) Kinsler slipped a little last year. You’d have to put this guy anywhere from No. 3 to No. 5. He’s not a carry-the-team kind of impact player. But that’s pretty high praise.”
Kipnis is the first drafted and developed Indians player to make the All-Star team since C.C. Sabathia. That doesn’t include international players who aren’t draft eligible but even that is a quick roll call (Fausto Carmona, Victor Martinez).
Even better for Indians’ fans scarred by departures of star players, Kipnis figures to be here a while. The Indians control Kipnis for four more years.
It makes too much sense for both sides not to commit to a long-term arrangement that would keep Kipnis, who turns 27 the day before the home opener, in an Indians’ uniform through a season or two of free agency.
“We’ve been consistent in our desire to want to keep him here and he’s been consistent in wanting to be here,” said Indians’ President Mark Shapiro. “It’s just a matter of whether you can lock in that value where both sides are comfortable.”
What makes Kipnis a great bet isn’t only his track record of relatively quick success at every level and his habit of moving relentlessly forward once he “gets it,” but also that – as Shapiro says – “he plays with a chip on his shoulder.”
Do that long enough, it’s not something a player does. It becomes something a player is. Kipnis still thinks of himself as:
• The guy who played at Kentucky for a $400 book scholarship and nearly quit baseball after being dismissed for breaking team rules,
• Was told he projected as a fourth outfielder despite making All Pac-10 first team his first year at Arizona.
• Initially considered the move to second base a “slap in the face.”
Once he accepted that second base was his fast track to the majors, Kipnis didn’t look back or go back.
Asked how he managed to keep his offensive approach together while trying to learn a new position – that’s not as easy as it sounds – he says, “They told me I just had to knock in more runs than I let in.”
Travis Fryman, the former Indians’ third baseman who was Kipnis’ manager at Mahoning Valley, was among the group that hit him balls that first day.
Fryman admits he was “probably the least optimistic” that Kipnis could make the transition. He also is the first to tell you Kipnis showed an ability to outperform himself when the lights went on.
“Fiercely competitive,” Fryman says. “He embraces the big moments in games. He wants to be the guy who’s hitting with the game on the line.”
First time Fryman saw video of Kipnis hitting, he quickly grabbed a second video of a different hitter, put them side by side and marveled at the similarities.
“I called him Little Giambi,” Fryman said. “His swing, where he was at impact. Amazingly similar. He could hit the ball a long way for somebody who’s not a physically big guy.”
Giambi and Kipnis saw the same thing in the video comparisons. Giambi calls him “the son I didn’t know I had.” Giambi’s presence in the Indians’ clubhouse has afforded Kipnis the opportunity to talk hitting with his mirror image at the plate.
“We’re almost identical right down to the way we point our toe,” Kipnis said, laughing. “He cocks his bat a little more than I do. But I keep telling him I have more power.”
The Giambi comparison boosted Kipnis’ confidence as a young hitter. It’s much better than hearing you swing the bat like a lefthanded Mario Mendoza after all.
The rest of his confidence came from results. He never didn’t hit.
“I’d get to a new level and after a couple weeks it was like, “Is this it?'”, Kipnis said. “I mean that in a good way. I’d wonder why I was building it up to be this impossible step. After a couple weeks you realize 94 miles an hour is 94 miles an hour no matter who’s throwing it. It’s still baseball.”
His first hit in the big leagues – four days after his callup -- was a walk-off single against the Angels. Two weeks into his rookie season, he hit home runs in four consecutive games. Three weeks later, he went 5-5 with three RBI against Detroit.
A slow start last year left Indians’ manager Terry Francona facing questions about how long he’d commit to Kipnis in the No. 3 slot, traditionally where a team’s most versatile and productive hitter bats. Francona never budged and in June Kipnis had a record-book month.
He hit .419 in June with four homers, 25 RBI and 12 doubles. He scored 17 runs. He stole nine bases. He had a .517 on-base percentage. It put him in the conversation with players named Cobb, Sisler, Speaker and Sewell for most productive calendar months.
A month later, representing the American League in the All-Star game in New York, Kipnis hit a run-scoring double off Atlanta closer Craig Kimbrel to pad the lead in a 3-0 AL win.
Earlier in the weekend, a MLB volunteer welcomed him by saying, “It’s an honor to have you here, Mr. Swisher.”
A few fans mistakenly asked his brother, Todd, for an autograph. The Kipnis boys didn’t set them straight.
“They should’ve looked a little closer at the baseball card instead of the body,” Kipnis said, laughing.
Giambi noticed a difference when Kipnis returned. He noticed a player enjoying that sense of belonging that comes from making an All-Star game, and embracing the responsibility that comes with it.
“They always say there are stepping stones in this game,” Giambi said. “A guy like Mike Trout is an exception. Last year was huge for Kip. This guy is on the fast track.”
Kipnis has always enjoyed – how do we say it – a looser environment. Coaches appreciate structure. Some in the Indians’ organization laughed last year when The Plain Dealer ran a story on players’ game-day routines:
Kipnis listed sleeping, eating, stretching, eating, napping some more, listening to music and pre-game sushi. It sounded like a college kid on break, minus the stretching.
What nobody questions is the way Kipnis plays the game. That hasn’t changed since he accepted the challenge of moving from the outfield and putting in hours of work with Fryman, Anthony Medrano in Arizona and Mike Sarbaugh in Columbus.
Medrano remembers Kipnis coming to Arizona two weeks early to work on the transition to second (something Kipnis still does).
“When he got called up the first time I felt like it was my own kid making the big leagues,” said Medrano. “He’s a special person and a special player.”
Kipnis plays the game the right way, as baseball people like to say. Meaning he gets his uniform dirty, is a better base stealer than his speed should allow, and can beat you with a bunt as easily as a home run.
He’s an elite hitter who shows up to work with a lunch pail attitude. If not a rare combination, it’s not commonplace.
In fact, image shapers in this city looking for a celebrity spokesman could do worse than Kipnis.
The latest campaign to market Cleveland embraces its gritty sophistication. And, well, here we have an All-Star second baseman nicknamed “Dirtbag” (for all the best baseball reasons), entering his prime and promising to only get better.
Twice chosen to represent the Indians in Major League Baseball’s “Face of the Franchise” fan voting, Kipnis embodies most of the talking points of the city promoters: tough, resilient, plain-talking, self-deprecating, better than advertised.
To borrow a phrase, that is positively Kipnis.
“I wouldn’t pretend to tell Mark (Shapiro) and Chris (Antonetti) what to do, but obviously he’s a core guy you’d like to extend,” said Hart.
After another All-Star game – maybe one where nobody asks the wrong Kipnis for his autograph – the Indians’ second baseman will be as recognizable outside Cleveland.
He admits he had that “Is this it?” moment in New York last July standing on second base. In a good way. And that he carried that sense of belonging into the last half of 2014.
“You’re surrounded by players you’ve looked up to and you suddenly realize, 'I can do this,'” said Kipnis. “My confidence went up in the second half. Even if I’d gone 0-4, I could tell myself I’m still a threat. The other team knows who I am. It’s a confidence boost.”
That’s saying something for a guy who’s never exactly lacked belief in himself.
"I think he can actually get better," Francona told reporters in Arizona this spring. "As he knows the league, as he knows himself, and as long as he stays healthy, I think he's going to get better."
When you consider this is only his third full season, Kipnis has covered a lot of ground. And only a little of it chewed dirt.
"I've suffered a great many tragedies in my life....most of them never happened". Mark Twain