2040
by civ ollilavad
Not really attempting to rank the thin ranks of Tribe prospects, but reviewing the rosters of the farm clubs for candidates, this is all I come up among position players:
Catcher, no one really. Lavisky and Lowery are having bad years. Monsalve hitting 270.. Roberto Perez is big league defender but can't hit; he could become of those career AAAA catchers. Charlie Valerio is hitting well and for power, splitting time between C and 1B; check back next year on him.
1b: Agullar's a slugger who doesn't slug that much. He has kept his average up and his strikeouts are not terrible. Not much of a fielder. Chen hasn't been a slugger since he got out of Class A. But he's hitting about 320 with lots of doubles; walks enough. Has this converted catcher learned to play 1st? Jerud Sabourin is hitting 300 with little power and is rated the best defenser in his league; that doesn't add up to much.
2b: Cord Phelps is hitting for lots of power this year. Tony Wolters has progressed well as one of the youngest in his league. Jose Ramirez didn't out of camp until June but has performed very well. Joe Wendle is hitting well for Mahoning Valley; I assume he'll have a career arc like Scott Pratt and other high round college middle IFs we have specialized in picking and not developing.
ss: Lindor has been rated our No. 1 prospect. Great fielder, hitting well enough at age 19. Ronnie Rodrigurez rated best ss in his league but makes beaucoup errors, lots of power for age 20. Dorsyss Paulino hitting up a storm at age 17 in Arizona. Juan Diaz had a cup of coffee with the Indians; he's hitting for power, avg 260, good defense.
3b: Giovanny Urshela rated a stellar defender is hitting much better in High A than he did in low A. Only 20. Jorge Martinez hits for average and power, not sure about his defense, hasn't graduated to a full season team in 3 years.
lf: Tim Fedroff. Breakthrough at AAA, hitting for great average which he's done before and uniquely demostrating power, doesn't steal much or walk much. Forget about Weglarz.
cf: Delvi Cid has been around for awhile in Class A but still young enough and having a decent year with the bat, still a fine basestealer although not up to his earlier pace. Don't know about his defense. Luigii Rodriguez 19 year old in Lake County runs well, surprising power, not great season but solid for his age. Tyler Naquin our 1st draft choice this year which usually guarantees failure; hasn't hit a pro homer and hasn't been promoted to a full season league. Bryson Myles probably is a little weak at all 5 tools, although should reach AAA.
rf: Anthony Santander, 17 year old RBI machine playing in Arizona, has all 5 tools to some extent. Jordan Smith is a good RF, hitting 300, not much power. 5 years older than Santander and just in Lake County.